Saturday, May 15, 2010

Post From Portsmouth

Portsmouth, New Hampshire, is one of those nicely-surviving old towns that you always mean to visit and spend a few days touring but usually don't. Lots of the old town stands as original buildings befitting one of our northern-most seaports. Some years ago when I was doing some work in New Hampshire, Eileen and I visited a large restored area called Strawbery Banke, accent on the peculiarities of spelling, a la shoppe. It was fun and perhaps even better than going to its more famous relative, Williamsburg, where we will be next weekend (and are unlikely to spend any time touring the tourist area).

I did drive through downtown today and enjoyed an early season farmers' market even if they ran out of lobster rolls by the time I arrived, so I had to have one at Bob's, the stand amidst the outlets across the bridge in Kittery, Maine. My raison de visite was the annual convention of the Horatio Alger Society, of which I have in my declining years become a more regular attendee. As with other such groups, the average age of members is rising and the number in attendance falling in direct proportion.

I've belonged to the society longer than almost all active members but have been an irregular attendee at the conventions owing to my travel schedule and conflicts. I enjoy knowing a number of the members all of whom I never would have known through any other likely way of meeting. Ive not hosted the convention--usually when I actually volunteer to do that it means I will somehow leave the group and be unable to deliver, sometimes causing hard feelings: I couldn't host the National Conference of Appellate Court Clerks because I changed jobs and some people took umbrage. I will try to do it one of these years, though, or risk being the oldest member who hasn't done it.

If you like book collecting, the convention is fun. I like late 19th century juvenile literature because of the Americana it conjures up for me. In an era without tv or movies or radio or Ipods, children read Alger and Oliver Optic and Henty and J. T. Trowbridge and Edward S. Ellis (the last two were American frontier adventure writers). We know that Lincoln enjoyed the rough humor of Artemus Ward. I find it enjoyable to be with people who know an immense amount about things like the third states of first editions, or the broken type on page 46 of another.

Alger wrote mostly in New York City and conveys a very definite picture of the metropolis in the 1870s and 1880s. He had limited ability at setting a plot--basically, he had one which he repeated about 100 times. But his descriptions of New York settings are worth knowing and his values are fine, as appropriate for us as for the Gilded Age inhabitants for whom he wrote.

It seems he gave most of his earnings to good causes such as the Newsboys Lodging House, and it may have been in the form of penance for this quietly defrocked Unitarian minister, who was thrown out of his pulpiy on Cape Cod for undisclosed reasons that are familiar to us as regards clergymen today. He also contributed to the American popular literature in yet another way: his assistant Edward Stratemyer finished six of his novels and them proceeded to invent, write, and eventually oversee a factory-like operation -- the Stratemyer Syndicate -- that produced Tom Swift, the BobbseyTwins, the Hardy Boys, Nancy Drew, and several other series for children.

The Society established an official repository for a fine collection of Alger at Northern Illinois University in DeKalb, Illinois, which isnt too far from O'Hare Airport. The retired librarian at NIU now lives in Durham, New Hampshire, and hosted this convention. The high point for me was returning to Newick's restaurant on Dover Point, where you can get the finest fried clams in the world, or at least the only ones I will deign to enjoy, on a level with Faidley's crabcakes in Lexington Market, Baltimore.

Thursday, April 29, 2010

The Other Mr. Goldstone

Richard Goldstone is one of the world's most distinguished jurists. He was outspoken in his opposition to apartheid in the bad old days in South Africa and he has been outstanding in his defense of liberty and liberties on South Africa's Constitutional Court. Despite the amazing success of South Africa in avoiding bloodshed--entirely, I suggest, because of the inspired leadership of Nelson Mandela, the conversion of this country from a bigoted authoritarian state to a true democratic republic has not been easy. Mandela will not be around forever, either. People like Goldstone have proven their mettle in a hard testing ground.

Benjamin Netanyahu, in contrast, has a reputation as someone who speaks out of both sides of his mouth. He owes his position as prime minister of Israel to the lawless settlers who doctor records and use force to steal land from Palestinians and block any peaceful resolution of the long-term issues. So clearly is he "owned" by the extreme right in Israel that he cannot deal reasonably with President Obama, so the latter quite reasonably pays him scant attention any more.

Netanyahu and his ilk have tried to stir up the worldwide Jewish community against Justice Goldstone because he led a UN-sponsored inquiry that said that both Israel and Hamas committed atrocities during the last war. They even tried to threaten Goldstone with bodily harm if he attended his nephew's bar mitzvah. This all reminds me of the nonsensical position espoused with some success in America some years ago by the late Norman Podhoretz that anyone who questioned any policy of the Israeli government was anti-Semitic.

Most people that Netanyahu now attacks want a fair settlement far more than he does. I think of Jimmy Carter and George Mitchell. Netanyahu's minions would have you believe that they too are anti-Semitic. Our president has tried mightily to have everyone in the Middle East see the U.S. as a fair dealer only focused on bringing peace to this beknighted region. Now that he is showing some success on the domestic front, his international standing and effectiveness may rise in tandem.

Note: In case you were wondering, the first Mr. Goldstone was the character in the movie musical version of Gypsy played by the late Benny Lessy, to whom Mama Rose--Rosalind Russell, but originally, of course, Ethel Merman--sings "Have an egg roll, Mr. Goldstone" when he decides to take a chance as a vaudeville operator on their act. Lessy was memorable in performing the part--he's just in one great long scene--without ever saying a word.

Tuesday, April 27, 2010

Reunions--Not in Vienna

Yes, that was the title of a rather talky Robert E. Sherwood play of the 30s that featured the Lunts and sometimes Noel Coward, I believe, which meant that even if it wasn't the greatest vehicle, they all must have delighted audiences. But I just returned from a 40th reunion--law school, no less. They did have some other reuning classes there and it was encouraging to see the far more populous 50th reunion class--complete with Mike Dukakis, tank-less this time--yes, they did look old.

This time, a nice number of friends showed up, so that made the reunion. Over the years, the law school has turned over all planning to the development people, and if they feel what they've done for a reunion weekend makes sense, their instinct is to do exactly the same thing again. I skipped most of the programs since the weather in Cambridge and Boston was spring-like and pleasant.

But I did make a class forum on retirement--led by a woman who was contemplating forced retirement from partnership at an old-line Boston firm where she was a partner in trusts and estates, naturally. She couldn't face life without that. My old friend and best man, Guy Blynn, remarked helpfully to me that 40 years ago, that firm wouldn't give him the time of day as the old ethnic walls were just beginning to break down. But we kept listening to these people whining about how their firms were effectively forcing them out by pushing them to delegate work to cheaper-billing associates. Again, Guy noted that since they were the partners, they had helped create this engine that dispatched its drivers before they were quite ready to be bounced.

He's fully retired and I'm semi-retired. I didn't think there was anything I would say about what I did that would interest most of the attendees, since I went in a rather different direction from all of them way back when. There were some very constructive ideas if anyone bothered to listen: a friend and classmate both at college and law school described how he had organized an entire program in his large law firm to represent people litigating their immigration status. Someone said to another old friend whose law firm had imploded and whose days as counsel at another had ended that he must have retired, only to elicit the far more straightforward response: "Hell no, I was fired!"

We did indulge in some nostalgia-tripping: when Noah Griffin arrived, he outlined a path that included walking through Longfellow's garden (the house isn't yet open for the summer), the monument opposite the State House on Beacon Hill to the Glorious 54th Regiment of Glory fame, where we met an excited re-enactor, and then the current Brattle Book Shop near the Common, always a wonderful place to spend some time searching for something you never knew you needed. Seamus at the Parker House ran through some of the amazing history of that famed hostelry. We even caught the tail end of the Princeton-Harvard lacrosse game, with the Crimson upsetting the favored Tigers.

Boston and Cambridge have changed a lot, especially on the dining front, but you wouldn't have known it from our choices. Lunch at probably the only true "joint" left in Harvard Square, Charlie's Kitchen, which now has a beer garden; late night snacking at the still-laden-with-MSG Hong Kong, and late dinner at the now ultra-unfashionable Anthony's Pier 4. Hey, they still make a nice broiled schrod. Sure, Legal is better but why go there when they're in your neighborhood.

My conclusion was that change is coming, albeit late, to my law school class. I remember my 25th, when there were four of us not in suits and the other three were from California. Now I bet half the attendees were both jacket-less and tie-less. You may think that's sexist but hey, there were 20 women in our entering class of 540. Now women make up 53% of a law school class.

The new dean spoke, describing all kinds of new initiatives and new courses, all of which made my head spin because, finally, in my old age, the place is getting much more open and broad-minded. It has adapted to changed times when not everyone will be heading for a large firm. I did smile when I heard that one "new" idea was to have required courses on Legislation and Negotiation in the first year. My wife learned Legislation from the late great Father Drinan at Georgetown back in the 80s and she's been teaching Negotiation 9and ADR) at GW for the past fifteen.

It's nice to see Harvard evolve but they are hardly the first. A bit like the time in World War II in the Pacific when somehow the Seabees managed to get set up on an island before the Marines arrived; thus the welcoming banner, "The Seabees are always happy to welcome the Marines".

Thursday, April 8, 2010

Kyrgyzstan and Coal

Since I was in Kyrgyzstan less than two years ago, I was most interested in the swift change of government that is occurring there. It appears to be something of a coup--starting with protests against price increases by an increasingly authoritarian government. Then this morning I heard a correspondent who had been there recently express the view that this shake-up had the Russians' hands all over it.

First I had been skeptical of the U.S., when our spokesman there merely expressed the view that people should restrain violence and proceed peacefully. Difficult to do when guns and major forces are being dispatched and used. I'm heading for a panel discussion this noon hour on the future of the Millenium Challenge Corporation. This is the government-funded entity that supported the project on which I was involved in Bishkek, Kyrgyzstan, back in late 2008.

The whole situation is starting to look like a late episode of Cold War strategizing: the radio correspondent took the position that the Cold War never has ended. The Russians would like the U.S. out of Central Asia; the U.S. needs the base in Kyrgyzstan for support of Afghanistan operations. Before we start criticizing the Russians, remember how we reacted when they sought to extend their influence to our backyards in Cuba and Central America.

Kyrgyzstan is a poor country, with some mineral resources (being mined mostly by a Canadian outfit), that has little going for it except Asian mountain tourism in the Hindu Kush and other high mountain places. It has not flourished since the breakup of the Soviet Union--unlike neighboring Kazakhstan, it has no oil. It is located quite far in the east of Central Asia and could well become closer to its eastern neighbor, China.

The government that appears to be on the way out has not been very good for the people but our role should be to encourage positive behavior on the part of the new regime. If it really will seek to improve conditions, the U.S. can be quite helpful if we think beyond Afghanistan. If this is a Russian ploy, we need to call it for what it is.

Speaking of good for the people, the coal disaster in West Virginia has the media being very careful in assessing blame, despite the hordes of violations of safety regulations. The last time I noticed this guy Blankenship was when he bought the West Virginia Supreme Court election and the 5-4 Supreme Court threw out his case where his bought judge provided the majority in his case. No one seems to have made a big deal out of the fact that one reason he has gotten away with poor compliance is the non-union status of his mines. Nobody wants a union until the proverbial stuff hits the fan and management is happy to meet all day and night to hold families' hands so they don't scream bloody murder to the media.

It's a shame that too many people today have never heard of the man who was once America's best-known labor leader, John Llewellyn Lewis, who led the coal miners. John L. would not have missed a beat in letting the world know whose fault this "tragedy" was: coal-owning corporate types like Blankenship who will sweat every dime out of the miners' hides.

Wednesday, March 24, 2010

Back in Moot Court

This week I've donned the judicial robe to sit six times on benches hearing arguments in the Jessup International Law Competition, which is held in Washington, D.C., this time each year. More than 100 teams from around the world compete--representing law schools and public policy programs--and the International Law Students Association manages to find some huge law firm to foot the bill. This year--White & Case; last year, Shearman & Sterling.

I got involved in this last year through the suggestion of my legal assistant on the Indonesia project I worked on in Jakarta about five years ago. She had represented the University of Indonesia law faculty in the Jessup Competition and then coached their term for several years. After winning a Fulbright to Boalt Hall at Berkeley, and passing the New York bar, she worked for an intellectual property firm in Austin and now is with a large Jakarta firm.

The competition requires all the teams to brief and argue a complex made-up case mythically set in the International Court of Justice in The Hague. The names of the countries are also made up but the legal issues are real. You may chuckle but in international law, the fact that a ship captain "discovered" a group of uninhabited islands in 1777, leaving a flag and a carved stone marker to show he was there, might be enough without more to support a successful claim derived from his being the first. Usually something commercial comes into play, so they have recently discovered oil near these islands, and the nearby nation that claims them versus a former colonial empire became independent right around the time that most of the South American countries did, in the 1820s.

There is a whole world of international law, made up of United Nations resolutions, ICJ and predecessor Permanent Court of Justice decisions, international conventions agreed to in Warsaw and Geneva, for example, and even a Convention that tells you to interpret other conventions, that one having been held in Vienna. There are all sorts of treaties, bilateral agreements, learned treatises, and other efforts to combine theories and precepts from both the Anglo-American common law and the European civil law.

I am always amazed that the concerned nations actually were willing on so many occasions to put their destinies in front of third-party panels or arbitrators. My favorite unlikely neutral was the one chosen in 1890 or so to decide the "Pig War" for control of the San Juan islands between British Columbia and Washington State--a conflict that left the remains of the British and American Camps as historic sites on San Juan Island. The Brits and Americans chose, of all people, Kaiser Wilhelm II. Perhaps the Kaiser was looking ahead because he seemed to come down on the side of the Americans when it came time to draw the line down through or around the islands.

The competition is fascinating to see how different students approach the task of argument. As with admiralty law, there are unusual terms: counsel are referred to as "Agents" and briefs are termed "Memorials." The argument style is a bit more formal than is common in the U.S., even the Supreme Court. If you make any kind of broad or conclusory statement, which might well serve to present your theory or underlying theme of the case, you will be peppered from the bench with demands for references to supporting authorities.

I've now sat with judges who are lawyers in Ghana, the Dominican Republic, and Germany this year and had an engaging conversation with a lawyer from Azerbaijan in the judges' lounge. To make my week complete, I long ago agreed to judge moot court arguments tomorrow night by some George Washington University law students. Amid their consideration of search provisions of criminal law, I might just ask them if they had considered the impact, say, of the Barcelona Traction case.

Thursday, March 11, 2010

Out of Court Sparring

It remains to be seen whether the latest little foray by Chief Justice John Roberts will stir up the peapatch or just die on the vine. I do admit that I've wondered what the Supreme Court is doing attending the State of the Union--my assumption is that it is a relatively recent "tradition" that brings the three branches together. I say recent because until FDR's time, presidents did not deliver their State of the Union reports before joint sessions of Congress at all, preferring to transmit them in writing.

Given that Roberts was an advocate and a fairly well-known one, prior to his being named to the bench, one might assume that he's used to a bit of give-and-take. I suppose that being in the House and having the President turn to you and your colleagues as he unloaded against one of your decisions was a surprise but Harry Truman's remark about heat and kitchens comes to mind. Roberts and his right-wing pals can push counsel around in their courtroom but apparently what he called "hollering" in the legislative arena was too much for his tender ears.

He should show up at the British House of Commons some day and hear them roaring as the debate heats up. Roberts seems pretty sure of himself for a man who has spent his life being insulated from the pressures most of us must endure. If it were up to me, the White House would up the ante in terms of castigating the campaign finance decision, one that went way beyond the bounds of what needed to be decided to impose the activism of the conservatives on us.

After all those years of whacking the hell out of the Warren Court, are conservatives now telling us that it's not right to blast the Supreme Court? Utter nonsense--there are too few ways of getting their attention since they can ignore anything they don't want to hear. Roberts kept his nose clean and the Democrats were afraid to vote him down as an inappropriate nominee because of his reactionary background, as they also were with Alito.

It's about time that Obama puts up some real liberals for judicial vacancies. The system won't work if only the conservatives nominate their true believers. If you wonder why no one on the Supreme Court merits a whole lot of respect, it's because we have sunk to nominating people without significant ideological records. All the so-called "liberals" on the bench are really what we used to call moderates: Stevens, a law firm partner from Chicago whom Gerry Ford put on the court; David Souter, known in New Hampshire as a conservative attorney-general; and Ruth Bader Ginsburg and Stephen Breyer, two mildly progressive academics. O'Connor quit so a fellow Republican president, even one she may not have liked a whole lot, could name her successor.

The whole business and all the fakery that goes on about the nominations makes me realize that the eminently pragmatic FDR had it right when he tried to pack the joint. He too had a Supreme Court majority that decided it would keep the government from dealing with the worst economic crisis in our history. This Supreme Court majority--Roberts and his pals--deserve to worry the way the Nine Old Men in the 30s did.

Friday, March 5, 2010

Under Wonderland?

Two Friday nights spent seeing films which opened that day: last week, The Ghost Writer and today, Alice in Wonderland. Both were definitely worth seeing. Early impressions: Pierce Brosnan is much more believable now that he's a bit over the hill rather than beautiful. And I've resisted the appeal of Johnny Depp for a long time but he's a delightful Mad Hatter. The Ghost Writer demonstrates that Roman Polanski has not lost his touch in the slightest. He was always great at creating a film with subtle menacing not horror or thriller.

Unlike a lot of people in this country today, I would cut him a break after all these years. Yes, he did the wrong thing by running--leaving aside whether he was guilty of the crime. But the system had set itself up to do a number on him and he saw no other way out. Remember it was his wife who was murdered. By the way, Polanski has some fun making Brosnan's character a bit of a dissolute Tony Blair. And then he shows how in the end the Establishment squeezes anything but its version of what happened out of the picture.

Back to the movies. Tim Burton has taken the impossible-to-dramatize work of Lewis Carroll and had some fun with it. Some of the wonderful characters are there--Alan Rickman voicing the Caterpillar, one of my absolute favorites, was superb. Stephen Fry, too, voicing the Cheshire Cat, was equally adept. It was all good fun with little traces here and there of the original. I do wish that in addition to "off with their heads," they had retained two of the Red Queen's other marvelous lines: "Sentence first, trial later" and "Don't you have to run as fast as you can to stay in the same place?"

We seem today only to want to emphasize feet of clay. Was Lewis Carroll a bit dodgy in his liking for little girls? I recall reading about the long life of Alice Liddell, supposedly the model for Alice in the books. She sounded in her recollections like he was hardly dangerous, just hard to understand. The books themselves are delightfully full of the illogical conundrums that only a brilliant mathematician like Charles Dodgson could conjure up.