It's always enlightening to read pop psychology which, of course, emerges from what is new research but has then been massaged and shaped, too often to fit existing inclinations, and yes, prejudices. Lately, some of the discussion that has been percolating for years about our educational system's denigrating the needs of boys has focused on two sometimes opposing themes.
The first argues that our traditional culture discourages any showing of empathy on the part of boys. In this view, boys are forced only to block and tackle, emphasize physical skills, and steer clear of anything that might be termed cultural, such as the arts, literature, or, for that matter, psychology itself. This theme holds that we are depriving boys of the benefits of civilization when all these pursuits are derided as "girly" or gay.
The second theme has it that boys are being constrained from being boys as a result of the gradual triumph of feminine values in our society, if not our politics. Indeed, some see the battle by the gun culture led by the NRA as a last stand by those in the U.S. desperate to preserve the vestiges of the frontier culture that valued physical strength and prowess with weapons, especially firearms, as the hallmark of our society.
Too often, this particular engagement in the overall "culture wars" fails to take note of what has happened to shift the focus of this topic: our working
world today no longer offers as many jobs that depend on brute strength.
Our society is becoming a "knowledge and information" one. What's too
bad is that many boys take to computers and information technology, and are even encouraged in the classroom and outside it to pursue their early interest, but
never progress past addiction to video games. It isn't because teachers
prefer girls, who generally but not always are better behaved. It's that
boys especially finish school--often not graduating or finishing college--without
the skills young people need today.
Popularizers in the media--beginning with the late Peter Drucker and moving on to current opinion molders such as Thomas Friedman--have been declaring for a long time that the old world of employment has changed, but only now, with the decline of manufacturing in the U.S., are we seeing the impact.
While my generation may recall how our elders in the 1950s and 1960s bemoaned the onset of rock'n'roll as certain to ruin our society, the surge in media dominance today means that many young people now are exposed to little more than rap music and music videos by way of "culture". I once had a young relative tell me that there was no longer a reason to read books because one could find any information needed online or through visual media, such as film. He wasn't referring to Kindles or Nooks, either, since whether or not we like e-books, they do serve as a means of making reading easier for many who have made this particular leap into the new world.
Thursday, September 26, 2013
Sunday, September 15, 2013
Mostly Mozart
While some sophisticated music lovers I've known have expressed great admiration for Mozart's The Abduction From the Seraglio, I've never found its plot at all convincing or even interesting. That does not, of course, diminish the delight in Mozart's music: it merely confirms for me that he really did need a comparable genius, Lorenzo da Ponte, to provide libretti for his three most sublime operas.
This afternoon, however, I enjoyed a wonderful production of Abduction (known also in its original German version as Die Entfuhring aus dem Serail) put on at Washington's Source Theater by The IN Series, which has specialized in delightful updatings of Mozart's operas, focusing up to now on the Da Ponte masterpieces. As with all great works, all of these can not only withstand this kind of production, but actually come away with even more lustre.
Today's production transposed the action to Judge Roy Bean's saloon, The Jersey Lily, named by him, as was the town where it and he were located, in 1882, after the renowned singer of those times, Lillie Langtry. Judge Bean, you may recall, was known as The Law West of the Pecos. In real life, alas, Judge Bean's idol, Miss Langtry, never made it to visit her fervent admirer until after his death. But here, it is he and his minions--especially one Osmond--who kidnap her and her maid. The still-tired plot then features the efforts of her lover, Belmont, and his friend to release her and escape from Texas.
This, of course, is no sillier than the singspiel plot provided to Mozart by his original librettists in Vienna. Belmonte struggles to free his beloved, Constanze (coincidentally, of course, the name of Mozart's long-suffering spouse) from the harem of the Pasha of some Middle Eastern state, and his encounter with the Pasha's chief guard, Osmin.
A fine troupe of strong young singers led the production with the most outstanding being bass Jeffrey Tarr as Osmond and soprano Heather Bingham as Lillie. The true heroine of the day, however, was Bari Bern, who wrote the English translation that shifted the scene of the opera from the Middle East to Texas and inserted Judge Roy Bean in place of the Pasha.
The libretto was clever and lent the whole production a positive attitude. It also permitted us to enjoy Mozart's fabulous composition of a succession of arias, duets, and a quartet. This fine production confirmed my view that great operatic works can benefit from new settings and changes in concept. It's a commonplace to chuckle at the outlandish opera productions often presented in European houses but all too often, our greatest companies remain excessively tied to tradition in the way they approach the operatic masterworks. The sprightly IN Series here in DC, helmed by Carla Hubner, continues to show the way to instilling renewed vigor into these grand vehicles.
This afternoon, however, I enjoyed a wonderful production of Abduction (known also in its original German version as Die Entfuhring aus dem Serail) put on at Washington's Source Theater by The IN Series, which has specialized in delightful updatings of Mozart's operas, focusing up to now on the Da Ponte masterpieces. As with all great works, all of these can not only withstand this kind of production, but actually come away with even more lustre.
Today's production transposed the action to Judge Roy Bean's saloon, The Jersey Lily, named by him, as was the town where it and he were located, in 1882, after the renowned singer of those times, Lillie Langtry. Judge Bean, you may recall, was known as The Law West of the Pecos. In real life, alas, Judge Bean's idol, Miss Langtry, never made it to visit her fervent admirer until after his death. But here, it is he and his minions--especially one Osmond--who kidnap her and her maid. The still-tired plot then features the efforts of her lover, Belmont, and his friend to release her and escape from Texas.
This, of course, is no sillier than the singspiel plot provided to Mozart by his original librettists in Vienna. Belmonte struggles to free his beloved, Constanze (coincidentally, of course, the name of Mozart's long-suffering spouse) from the harem of the Pasha of some Middle Eastern state, and his encounter with the Pasha's chief guard, Osmin.
A fine troupe of strong young singers led the production with the most outstanding being bass Jeffrey Tarr as Osmond and soprano Heather Bingham as Lillie. The true heroine of the day, however, was Bari Bern, who wrote the English translation that shifted the scene of the opera from the Middle East to Texas and inserted Judge Roy Bean in place of the Pasha.
The libretto was clever and lent the whole production a positive attitude. It also permitted us to enjoy Mozart's fabulous composition of a succession of arias, duets, and a quartet. This fine production confirmed my view that great operatic works can benefit from new settings and changes in concept. It's a commonplace to chuckle at the outlandish opera productions often presented in European houses but all too often, our greatest companies remain excessively tied to tradition in the way they approach the operatic masterworks. The sprightly IN Series here in DC, helmed by Carla Hubner, continues to show the way to instilling renewed vigor into these grand vehicles.
Tuesday, September 3, 2013
War
Last month I was reading two of Graham Greene's fantastically prescient novels, The Quiet American and Our Man in Havana. His perception of where events were headed in Saigon (early 1950s) and Havana (later 1950s) led me to imagining how much better off the U.S. might have been if Greene had been paid more attention by our policymakers. (It probably didn't make him any more attractive to them that he was defiantly anti-American, mostly, one feels, after reading these novels, because he felt we were doing a bad job replacing the Brits as the world's movers and shakers--or even now, as the surviving superpower.)
If you read these two novels, you will see how he anticipates the gradual replacement of the French by the U.S. as the equivalent of the colonial power in Viet Nam, and the likelihood that the corrupt Batista regime in Cuba would be overthrown by revolutionaries of some sort, who were predictably less than thrilled with the U.S.'s then-common support of dictators in Latin America like Batista.
So after three presidents--Eisenhower, Kennedy, and Johnson--got deeper into Viet Nam--yes, the first two didn't go that far but they definitely set the stage and then some, it took many years to defuse the domino theory as the key element in American foreign policy in Asia. Then we had the totally irresponsible invasion of Iraq premised on a patchwork of lies and a needless invasion of Afghanistan--one had thought that the result of the 9/11 act of terror should have been a focused search for Bin Laden, not a wholesale invasion of two countries.
President Obama seemed incapable of appreciating that yes, we had invaded Afghanistan and deposed the Taliban, only to let them return as we shifted to an even less relevant theatre: Iraq, but that we still didn't need to be in Afghanistan since no one from the outside has ever been able to end up victorious in that unwholesome atmosphere.
He has shown some success--not that he gets much credit from an ignorant media. Under his leadership, the objective of getting Bin Laden was accomplished and Obama managed to accomplish some limited goals in Libya without committing troops on the ground and by rallying allies. Perfect--no, and his staff let him down by ignoring the shaky situation in Libya so as to allow terrorists to storm the Benghazi consulate and then to put out some b.s. about the event rather than play it straight. Had it not been for that mishap, Libya might stand as a success--sure, a qualified one, but a success all the same for intervening without getting into a prolonged conflict.
So now Obama is rightfully reluctant to commit to major involvement in Syria. Yes, he should have exercised the limited use-of-force option some time ago but it still can be a good approach. And he should be given credit for involving Congress--both for satisfying those (some friends of mine among them) who believe that Congressional action is mandatory, and for assuring that the people's representatives charged with making the decision to go to war are on board.
If you read these two novels, you will see how he anticipates the gradual replacement of the French by the U.S. as the equivalent of the colonial power in Viet Nam, and the likelihood that the corrupt Batista regime in Cuba would be overthrown by revolutionaries of some sort, who were predictably less than thrilled with the U.S.'s then-common support of dictators in Latin America like Batista.
So after three presidents--Eisenhower, Kennedy, and Johnson--got deeper into Viet Nam--yes, the first two didn't go that far but they definitely set the stage and then some, it took many years to defuse the domino theory as the key element in American foreign policy in Asia. Then we had the totally irresponsible invasion of Iraq premised on a patchwork of lies and a needless invasion of Afghanistan--one had thought that the result of the 9/11 act of terror should have been a focused search for Bin Laden, not a wholesale invasion of two countries.
President Obama seemed incapable of appreciating that yes, we had invaded Afghanistan and deposed the Taliban, only to let them return as we shifted to an even less relevant theatre: Iraq, but that we still didn't need to be in Afghanistan since no one from the outside has ever been able to end up victorious in that unwholesome atmosphere.
He has shown some success--not that he gets much credit from an ignorant media. Under his leadership, the objective of getting Bin Laden was accomplished and Obama managed to accomplish some limited goals in Libya without committing troops on the ground and by rallying allies. Perfect--no, and his staff let him down by ignoring the shaky situation in Libya so as to allow terrorists to storm the Benghazi consulate and then to put out some b.s. about the event rather than play it straight. Had it not been for that mishap, Libya might stand as a success--sure, a qualified one, but a success all the same for intervening without getting into a prolonged conflict.
So now Obama is rightfully reluctant to commit to major involvement in Syria. Yes, he should have exercised the limited use-of-force option some time ago but it still can be a good approach. And he should be given credit for involving Congress--both for satisfying those (some friends of mine among them) who believe that Congressional action is mandatory, and for assuring that the people's representatives charged with making the decision to go to war are on board.
Thursday, August 22, 2013
King Arthur Revisited
Last weekend I saw Glimmerglass Opera's production of Lerner & Loewe's Camelot, a musical I'd not had a chance to revisit since viewing its original Broadway production in 1961. It's a wonderful musical with an unusual twisted history. First, it followed their smash hit, My Fair Lady, which was still running when Camelot opened. While the show had a good run, largely because of the huge advance sale stimulated by My Fair Lady's success, reviews were only mildly favorable.
It has since been concluded that this situation was the result of the illness and consequent withdrawal of Moss Hart as director. He'd staged My Fair Lady and was already an acknowledged Broadway genius, added on to his status as a playwright in tandem with George S. Kaufman. When he returned some months after the show opened, he re-staged it to great effect, so that those who saw it then said that had he been able to prepare the show for opening night, it would have been a critical smash.
Glimmerglass put on a fine performance. Strongest was David Pittsinger as Arthur, and this year's artist-in-residence, Nathan Gunn, was Lancelot. Andriana Churchman put on a nice showing which in some ways even conjured up recollection of the now-legendary Julie Andrews as Guenevere. I found that Pittsinger was a strong singer, probably with a better voice than the wonderful Richard Burton, although no one is likely to act better than Burton. Gunn, alas, did not to my hearing come close to matching the roaring performance of Robert Goulet, in his Broadway debut, as Lancelot, especially in the blockbuster ballad, If Ever I Would Leave You--he was better in the lighter C'est Moi.
Camelot was drawn from the delightful re-telling of the Arthurian legends by T.H. White, The Once and Future King. That novel was once described by a critic as "the Middle Ages--not as they were but as they should have been." Seeing the show prompted me to pull out Volume Two of the classic Bulfinch's Mythology--The Age of Chivalry, to refresh myself on the stories. It was a fine excursion.
It has since been concluded that this situation was the result of the illness and consequent withdrawal of Moss Hart as director. He'd staged My Fair Lady and was already an acknowledged Broadway genius, added on to his status as a playwright in tandem with George S. Kaufman. When he returned some months after the show opened, he re-staged it to great effect, so that those who saw it then said that had he been able to prepare the show for opening night, it would have been a critical smash.
Glimmerglass put on a fine performance. Strongest was David Pittsinger as Arthur, and this year's artist-in-residence, Nathan Gunn, was Lancelot. Andriana Churchman put on a nice showing which in some ways even conjured up recollection of the now-legendary Julie Andrews as Guenevere. I found that Pittsinger was a strong singer, probably with a better voice than the wonderful Richard Burton, although no one is likely to act better than Burton. Gunn, alas, did not to my hearing come close to matching the roaring performance of Robert Goulet, in his Broadway debut, as Lancelot, especially in the blockbuster ballad, If Ever I Would Leave You--he was better in the lighter C'est Moi.
Camelot was drawn from the delightful re-telling of the Arthurian legends by T.H. White, The Once and Future King. That novel was once described by a critic as "the Middle Ages--not as they were but as they should have been." Seeing the show prompted me to pull out Volume Two of the classic Bulfinch's Mythology--The Age of Chivalry, to refresh myself on the stories. It was a fine excursion.
Friday, August 16, 2013
Exciting Dutchman
Tonight was a chance to see and hear a total delight--without a doubt, the Glimmerglass Festival performance of Wagner's The Flying Dutchman (Der Fliegende Hollaender) was the best of several I've seen over the years. Mostly, it was director Francesca Zambello's imaginative production that made the evening so memorable. John Keenan led the company orchestra in a spirited rendition of the wonderful score.
The stage featured much in the way of nautical motifs--lots of ropes and fanciful representations of sails and decks and gunwhales. The screen at the rear of the stage benefitted from use of gradual blackout and the ensemble did a nice job of dancing what appeared to be traditional sailors' steps. I found the cast generally excellent with Melody Moore as Senta, the heroine who strives to save the haunted and cursed title character, and Peter Volpe as Daland, her mercenary sea-captain father, a fine bass, the standouts. Jay Hunter Morris, who hit the Wagnerian big time as Siegfried in the Met's massive Ring series, was a strong Erik in a supporting role.
The performance worked the way festival opera presentations should: a production broke new ground in its conception and combined with excellent orchestral backing to give the audience a wonderful exposure to Wagner's finest early work. The pre-performance lecture emphasized how in Dutchman he was still utilizing many of the approaches of Italian opera, especially the bel canto era of Donizetti, Bellini, and Rossini which had just preceded Wagner's (and Verdi's) birth(s) 200 years ago. So this Wagner opera has duets and trios as well as recognizable arias, which were mechanisms he moved past by the time of the later masterpieces such as the Ring operas.
Glimmerglass is now on the top level of American summer opera festivals, joining Opera Theatre of Saint Louis, which I've been lucky enough to visit, and the Santa Fe Opera, which I still hope to see one of these days. Ms. Zambello, the director tonight who also head the festival is also in charge of the Washington National Opera, where I'm looking forward to seeing in the next two months productions of Tristan und Isolde, and with even more expectation to Verdi's La Forza del Destino, one of my personal favorites.
The stage featured much in the way of nautical motifs--lots of ropes and fanciful representations of sails and decks and gunwhales. The screen at the rear of the stage benefitted from use of gradual blackout and the ensemble did a nice job of dancing what appeared to be traditional sailors' steps. I found the cast generally excellent with Melody Moore as Senta, the heroine who strives to save the haunted and cursed title character, and Peter Volpe as Daland, her mercenary sea-captain father, a fine bass, the standouts. Jay Hunter Morris, who hit the Wagnerian big time as Siegfried in the Met's massive Ring series, was a strong Erik in a supporting role.
The performance worked the way festival opera presentations should: a production broke new ground in its conception and combined with excellent orchestral backing to give the audience a wonderful exposure to Wagner's finest early work. The pre-performance lecture emphasized how in Dutchman he was still utilizing many of the approaches of Italian opera, especially the bel canto era of Donizetti, Bellini, and Rossini which had just preceded Wagner's (and Verdi's) birth(s) 200 years ago. So this Wagner opera has duets and trios as well as recognizable arias, which were mechanisms he moved past by the time of the later masterpieces such as the Ring operas.
Glimmerglass is now on the top level of American summer opera festivals, joining Opera Theatre of Saint Louis, which I've been lucky enough to visit, and the Santa Fe Opera, which I still hope to see one of these days. Ms. Zambello, the director tonight who also head the festival is also in charge of the Washington National Opera, where I'm looking forward to seeing in the next two months productions of Tristan und Isolde, and with even more expectation to Verdi's La Forza del Destino, one of my personal favorites.
Wednesday, July 31, 2013
Gershwin and The Heat
Last Thursday we enjoyed a wonderful evening of Gershwin at the Baltimore Symphony playing at Strathmore in North Bethesda. First of all, the hall and its acoustics are superb. Second, the orchestra and soloist did a magnificent rendition of Rhapsody in Blue. This was the high point of the evening--all of the themes were presented with precision and brio by all of the orchestra's sections. The opening number was a suite of Leonard Bernstein's music from On the Town, which provided a nice start.
The rest of the Gershwin program, though never less than pleasing, was somewhat anticlimactic, partly because the orchestra did such a fine job on Rhapsody in Blue and also because the rest of the pieces were either not up to it musically or the selection could have been better. This was especially the story with the suite from Porgy and Bess. Yes, it had a few of the great songs, including Summertime, I'm On My Way, Bess, You Is My Woman Now, and I Got Plenty o'Nuttin. But where were Sportin' Life's two terrific numbers--It Ain't Necessarily So and There's a Boat Leavin' Soon for New York? And alas, after the rhapsody, An American in Paris is a slighter composition. I almost missed not only Gene Kelly's dancing his way through the movie but George Guetary's cornball "I'm on a Stairway to Paradise."
Then a few nights later, we took in a summer movie, The Heat. If you haven't seen it, it's a girl-buddy vehicle for Sandra Bullock and Melissa McCarthy, one a sleek, uptight FBI agent and the other an out-of-shape, totally street-smart Boston cop. Lots of character and lots of conflict follow. The idea was good, some of the lines and scenes are funny, but on the whole, it is written and played far too broadly (no pun intended) and descends into all-too-typical Hollywood silliness.
The rest of the Gershwin program, though never less than pleasing, was somewhat anticlimactic, partly because the orchestra did such a fine job on Rhapsody in Blue and also because the rest of the pieces were either not up to it musically or the selection could have been better. This was especially the story with the suite from Porgy and Bess. Yes, it had a few of the great songs, including Summertime, I'm On My Way, Bess, You Is My Woman Now, and I Got Plenty o'Nuttin. But where were Sportin' Life's two terrific numbers--It Ain't Necessarily So and There's a Boat Leavin' Soon for New York? And alas, after the rhapsody, An American in Paris is a slighter composition. I almost missed not only Gene Kelly's dancing his way through the movie but George Guetary's cornball "I'm on a Stairway to Paradise."
Then a few nights later, we took in a summer movie, The Heat. If you haven't seen it, it's a girl-buddy vehicle for Sandra Bullock and Melissa McCarthy, one a sleek, uptight FBI agent and the other an out-of-shape, totally street-smart Boston cop. Lots of character and lots of conflict follow. The idea was good, some of the lines and scenes are funny, but on the whole, it is written and played far too broadly (no pun intended) and descends into all-too-typical Hollywood silliness.
Sunday, July 28, 2013
Why FDR Deserves Praise
Two reviews in today's NY Times book review discuss recent studies of FDR's battle against the isolationists and other "anti-interventionists" in 1939 and 1940 before Pearl Harbor brought us into World War II. FDR, the reviewer noted, learned from the disastrous court-packing fight of 1937 and the failure to defeat the Southern Democrat-Republican reactionaries in the 1938 midterm. He drew from those setbacks the principle of not getting ahead of the American public; instead, he did what he could to move that public toward more progressive positions and in the interim, designed and passed Lend-Lease to keep the British in the fight until we could join them.
So when I read all the recent denouncing of FDR for not advancing the battle to save or rescue the Jews of Europe that a variety of so-called historians are propagating, I recognize that we risk making major errors when we charge historical figures with espousing and acting on all of our current values. Of course, it would have been better if we had bombed the rail lines to Auschwitz and if FDR had cracked down on the anti-Semites in the State Department who kept Jewish refugees out of the U.S. But FDR understood--as it is mighty hard for us to appreciate today--that there were strong forces in the U.S. then who both favored isolationism and were defiantly anti-Semitic.
1940 was not the same as 2013. Lindbergh--portrayed as a potential candidate who might well have defeated FDR in the 1940 election in Philip Roth's masterful novel, The Plot Against America--came out and accused FDR of "warmongering" because of Jewish influence. Roosevelt understood that if the effort to prepare the nation for war was perceived as based on any interest in helping the Jews, the whole campaign would be doomed from the start.
We don't encounter this kind of situation today. Of course, some might say that world antagonism to the right-wing Israeli government's policies is Anti-Semitism, but this is nothing close to the real Anti-Semitism and appeasement of the Nazis that was a powerful force in the pre-World War II U.S. Today's right-wing Jewish supporters of Bibi have made it hard for Jews to oppose Israeli government policy but many of us who love Israel despair for its future if these misguided policies continue. But back in 1940, there were real, rootin-tootin Anti-Semites whom FDR had to take on.
We know from Ira Katznelson's wonderful recent history, Fear Itself, about the deal FDR had to make with the Southern Democrats to get the New Deal enacted into law: he abandoned any effort to desegregate the South or give blacks civil rights. Bad deal? Absolutely. Did he have a real choice? Probably not. So when you read this tripe about how FDR let the Jews down, take a look at the histories reviewed today--one is entitled Rendezvous With Destiny, a title previously used for the wonderful history of the New Deal by Eric Goldman--and try to imagine an America in the pre-WW II period when even shrewd and progressive politicians like Franklin D. Roosevelt saw how they needed to bring the U.S. public along for the crucial fight--the war against the Nazis and Japan, and that that was no easy challenge.
So when I read all the recent denouncing of FDR for not advancing the battle to save or rescue the Jews of Europe that a variety of so-called historians are propagating, I recognize that we risk making major errors when we charge historical figures with espousing and acting on all of our current values. Of course, it would have been better if we had bombed the rail lines to Auschwitz and if FDR had cracked down on the anti-Semites in the State Department who kept Jewish refugees out of the U.S. But FDR understood--as it is mighty hard for us to appreciate today--that there were strong forces in the U.S. then who both favored isolationism and were defiantly anti-Semitic.
1940 was not the same as 2013. Lindbergh--portrayed as a potential candidate who might well have defeated FDR in the 1940 election in Philip Roth's masterful novel, The Plot Against America--came out and accused FDR of "warmongering" because of Jewish influence. Roosevelt understood that if the effort to prepare the nation for war was perceived as based on any interest in helping the Jews, the whole campaign would be doomed from the start.
We don't encounter this kind of situation today. Of course, some might say that world antagonism to the right-wing Israeli government's policies is Anti-Semitism, but this is nothing close to the real Anti-Semitism and appeasement of the Nazis that was a powerful force in the pre-World War II U.S. Today's right-wing Jewish supporters of Bibi have made it hard for Jews to oppose Israeli government policy but many of us who love Israel despair for its future if these misguided policies continue. But back in 1940, there were real, rootin-tootin Anti-Semites whom FDR had to take on.
We know from Ira Katznelson's wonderful recent history, Fear Itself, about the deal FDR had to make with the Southern Democrats to get the New Deal enacted into law: he abandoned any effort to desegregate the South or give blacks civil rights. Bad deal? Absolutely. Did he have a real choice? Probably not. So when you read this tripe about how FDR let the Jews down, take a look at the histories reviewed today--one is entitled Rendezvous With Destiny, a title previously used for the wonderful history of the New Deal by Eric Goldman--and try to imagine an America in the pre-WW II period when even shrewd and progressive politicians like Franklin D. Roosevelt saw how they needed to bring the U.S. public along for the crucial fight--the war against the Nazis and Japan, and that that was no easy challenge.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)